Event
Ein Lochkartenverfahren für Differentialgleichungen
In 1941 Lillian Feinstein and Martin Schwarzschild published a paper on the automatic integration of linear second-order differential equations using punched-card machines. Such mathematical methods mattered for scientific computation; the details of this particular method remain open until the full paper is examined. Bibliographic evidence
A later historical study describes Feinstein’s work at Columbia University’s astronomical punched-card laboratory, referring to Eckert’s 1940 book. It does not establish the division of contributions to the paper. Columbia’s timeline dates Feinstein’s hiring into the laboratory to 1936; Herbert Grosch retrospectively gives 1938. Personnel records have not been checked. Date comparison Historical study
In a 1941 paper Schwarzschild studied stellar pulsations using punched-card machines and acknowledged Feinstein’s assistance. He reported 74 outward integrations and the same number inward. A footnote explicitly says the improved joint method was developed after these computations. Astronomy paper
In 1952 Bruno de Finetti cited the 1941 paper when explaining finite differences. His simplified example provides a later perspective on the mathematical idea and does not replace examination of the original procedure. Source
A 1948 conference volume retrospectively describes a special multiplying punch as the main machine in a paper by Feinstein and Schwarzschild. Its identification as the 1941 paper remains tentative because only a search excerpt has been examined; the Type 602 discussed in the comparison is not evidence of its use in 1941. Source note
Their follow-up paper in 1947 addresses higher-order equations.
Sources
Astronomieaufsatz von 1941: frühere Berechnung, Mitarbeit und zeitliche Abgrenzung.
Bibliografien und Forschungsgeschichte; Originalaufsatz nicht im Volltext geprüft.
Offen
Volltext und Beiträge der beiden Autoren prüfen; Feinsteins Eintrittsjahr ins Labor gesondert klären.